Why AC for Transmission?

Alternating current (AC) is the standard for electrical power transmission worldwide. But why is AC preferred over direct current (DC)? This article explores the key reasons behind this choice, focusing on technical, economic, and practical advantages.

Introduction to Power Transmission

Power transmission involves sending electricity from generation plants to consumers over long distances. The goal is to minimize losses and ensure efficient delivery. Two types of current are used: AC and DC. While DC has its applications, AC dominates high-voltage transmission due to its inherent properties.

Key Advantages of AC Transmission

1. Voltage Transformation with Transformers

One of the most significant advantages of AC is the ability to change voltage levels easily using transformers. Transformers work on the principle of electromagnetic induction and can step up voltage for transmission and step it down for distribution.

• Step-up Transformers: Voltage is increased at the generating station to reduce current and minimize losses.
• Step-down Transformers: Voltage is reduced at substations for safe distribution to consumers.

DC transmission requires complex and expensive converters (rectifiers and inverters) for voltage changes, making AC more practical and cost-effective.

2. Lower Transmission Losses

Power loss in transmission lines is given by the formula P_loss = I²R, where I is current and R is resistance. To minimize losses, current should be as low as possible.

AC allows high voltage transmission, which reduces current for the same power (P = VI). For example, transmitting 100 MW at 400 kV AC requires less current than at lower voltages. Transformers enable this voltage boost without additional equipment.

DC can also achieve high voltages, but the conversion process introduces inefficiencies and costs.

3. Synchronization and Grid Integration

AC systems operate at a fixed frequency (typically 50 or 60 Hz), allowing multiple generators to synchronize easily. This creates interconnected grids where power can be shared across regions.

DC systems require precise control to maintain stability, and integrating multiple sources is more challenging. AC's natural synchronization makes it ideal for large-scale power systems.

4. Cost-Effectiveness

AC infrastructure is cheaper to build and maintain. Transformers are relatively inexpensive compared to DC converters. Additionally, AC lines can carry more power per conductor due to the skin effect and other factors.

While DC has lower losses over very long distances (e.g., HVDC for submarine cables), AC is more economical for most terrestrial transmission networks.

5. Historical and Technological Maturity

AC technology has been developed and refined for over a century. Nikola Tesla's AC system won over Thomas Edison's DC in the "War of Currents." The extensive existing infrastructure and expertise make AC the default choice.

Comparison with DC Transmission

DC transmission has advantages in specific scenarios:

• Long-Distance Transmission: DC has lower losses for distances over 600-800 km due to no reactive power issues.
• Undersea Cables: DC is preferred for submarine links as it avoids capacitance issues in AC cables.
• Asynchronous Connections: DC can connect grids with different frequencies without synchronization problems.

However, for most power systems, AC's benefits outweigh DC's. Modern HVDC systems are used where AC isn't feasible, but they add complexity and cost.

Challenges and Modern Developments

AC transmission isn't without issues:

• Reactive Power: AC lines have capacitance and inductance, leading to reactive power flow that can cause voltage instability.
• Skin Effect: At high frequencies, current concentrates on the conductor surface, increasing resistance.
• Corona Loss: High voltages can cause ionization of air around conductors.

These are mitigated through compensation devices like capacitors and reactors. Emerging technologies like flexible AC transmission systems (FACTS) enhance AC grid performance.

Conclusion

AC's superiority in power transmission stems from its compatibility with transformers, lower costs, and ease of integration into large grids. While DC excels in niche applications, AC remains the backbone of global electricity transmission. Understanding these principles is crucial for electrical engineers designing efficient power systems.

For more articles on power systems, check out our blog.